New Welcome to our refreshed site — same trusted community, elevated experience.

Journal

Your Excitement Is Killing the Deal

Look. Nobody taught you this in sales training because sales training wants you to be excited. Excitement looks like passion on a slide deck. It photographs well at the kickoff. But here is the truth the…

Published on

September 21, 2026

Written by

Gary Peterson

Look. Nobody taught you this in sales training because sales training wants you to be excited. Excitement looks like passion on a slide deck. It photographs well at the kickoff. But here is the truth the numbers will tell you if you are honest enough to look: the seller who needs the deal the most is usually the one who loses it.

You had the meeting. It went well. You could feel it. They said they would circle back, and then they didn’t, and so you followed up. You added warmth. You added urgency. You told them how excited you were to partner. You did exactly what passion is supposed to look like.

And they went quiet.

This is not bad luck. This is not a timing issue. This is your energy arriving before your value, and the market does not wait for you to sort that out. Esteemed’s philosophy puts it in one line –  excitement doesn’t close deals. If people don’t know you, your excitement scares them. It reads as need. Need reads as pressure and pressure, in a world where everyone’s attention is already stretched to nothing, is the fastest way to make a smart adult stop answering your emails.

Hope is not a strategy. Attachment is not a pipeline. Write that somewhere you will see it.

What actually works is almost the opposite of what your ego wants to send.

When a deal goes quiet, you do not send a longer pitch. You send a pattern interrupt. Four moves, no theater, no performance of enthusiasm.

First, state the data. No emotion. Just the facts. We met on the 12th. You were going to review with your team by Friday. I haven’t heard back. That is it. You are not guilting them. You are not implying anything. You are reading the record out loud.

Second, say “I don’t know.” Three words that most salespeople are too proud to write. You are not accusing anyone of ghosting. You are admitting the gap and leaving space for the truth to show up. That is harder than it sounds. Your ego wants to fill the silence with reasons why you are still worth it. Do not.

Third, offer one easy yes. A fifteen-minute call. A one-line reply. Not a proposal. Not a dinner. Not another presentation. Something so small that saying no to it would feel strange.

Fourth, and this is the whole game: make no okay. Say it explicitly. If now isn’t the right time, that’s completely fine, just tell me.

The follow-ups that fail try to persuade. The ones that work give an exit. When “no” and “not now” are safe answers, people come out of hiding. They reply. Sometimes they even say yes, because yes finally feels like a choice instead of a trap.

Run this cleanly and you get a response a startling share of the time. More importantly, you get the truth, and truth is what a forecast is made of. Ghosts are not.

Here is the self-awareness piece nobody wants to hear: to send that email, you have to put down the story that this deal would save your quarter. You have to put down the need to be liked. You have to stop performing. Stuart Wilde, in the material we teach, nails it: when you lean on people, it is a sign of insecurity, not care. Selling from strength is calm. Selling from equality means you do not emotionally borrow against the buyer’s goodwill.

The market can smell desperation. It always could. The question is whether you are honest enough with yourself to stop sending it.

State the data. Admit what you don’t know. Offer one easy yes. Make no okay.

You are not chasing them. You are creating an environment where the truth can show up.

Be Esteemed.